Get Your Scrum On: The Value of Planning Poker in Agile Development

Introduction

Planning Poker is a widely used estimation technique in Agile development that helps teams estimate the effort required for each product backlog item. It is a collaborative and consensus-building process that enables teams to arrive at a shared understanding of the complexity and effort required for each item.

In Agile development, estimation is critical as it helps teams plan and prioritize work effectively. It allows teams to identify and address potential roadblocks early in the process, enabling them to deliver high-quality products within the given timelines. Traditional estimation techniques often fall short in providing accurate and reliable estimates, resulting in project delays and budget overruns.

Planning Poker is an estimation technique that has gained widespread popularity in Agile development due to its effectiveness in providing accurate and reliable estimates. It helps teams estimate the effort required for each product backlog item based on a consensus-driven approach that ensures everyone on the team has a shared understanding of the work to be done.

In this article, we will explore the basics of Planning Poker and its importance in Agile development. We will discuss the key components of the Planning Poker process, the benefits it offers, and the techniques and best practices that teams can use to conduct successful Planning Poker sessions. We will also highlight the common pitfalls that teams should be aware of to ensure that their Planning Poker sessions are effective in providing accurate and reliable estimates. By the end of this article, you will have a solid understanding of Planning Poker and how it can benefit your Agile development efforts.

Understanding the Planning Poker Process

Planning Poker is an estimation technique that was first introduced by James Grenning in 2002. It was inspired by the Delphi method, a consensus-building technique used in forecasting and decision-making. Planning Poker is now widely used in Agile development as a collaborative and effective method for estimating the effort required for each product backlog item.

The key components of the Planning Poker process include a deck of estimation cards, a moderator or facilitator, and a team of developers, testers, and other stakeholders who participate in the estimation process.

The Planning Poker process involves several steps:

Backlog Refinement: The team reviews the product backlog items and selects the items to be estimated in the upcoming Planning Poker session.
Introduction: The moderator introduces the Planning Poker process and explains the rules and guidelines for the estimation process.
Discussion: The moderator reads the product backlog item and facilitates a discussion among the team members to clarify any questions or concerns related to the item.
Individual Estimation: Each team member selects an estimation card that represents their estimate of the effort required for the product backlog item.
Reveal: All team members reveal their estimation cards simultaneously.
Discussion: The team discusses the differences in the estimates and the rationale behind each estimation.
Consensus: The team selects a final estimation that represents a consensus-based effort required for the product backlog item.
Record: The final estimation is recorded, and the team moves on to the next product backlog item.

The estimation cards used in Planning Poker typically include a range of numbers, such as 0, 1/2, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 20, 40, 100, and a question mark card. The significance of the cards lies in the fact that they represent a relative estimate of the effort required for each product backlog item, rather than an absolute estimate. The team estimates the effort required for the smallest, simplest, and most well-understood items as 0, and all other items are estimated based on the relative complexity and effort required to complete them compared to the smallest item.

In conclusion, the Planning Poker process is a collaborative and effective method for estimating the effort required for each product backlog item in Agile development. It involves a deck of estimation cards, a moderator, and a team of developers, testers, and other stakeholders who participate in the estimation process. The process involves several steps, including backlog refinement, introduction, discussion, individual estimation, reveal, discussion, consensus, and record. The estimation cards used in Planning Poker represent a relative estimate of the effort required for each product backlog item and play a significant role in the estimation process.

Benefits of Planning Poker

Planning Poker is a widely used estimation technique in Agile development that offers several benefits for teams. Here are some of the key benefits of using Planning Poker in estimation:

Reduction of Bias and Variance: Traditional estimation techniques often suffer from bias and variance, resulting in inaccurate and unreliable estimates. Planning Poker helps reduce bias and variance in estimates by promoting a consensus-driven approach that encourages all team members to participate in the estimation process. This approach ensures that estimates are based on a shared understanding of the product backlog items, resulting in more accurate and reliable estimates.
Increased Team Collaboration: Planning Poker fosters collaboration among team members by encouraging open and honest discussion during the estimation process. Team members are encouraged to share their perspectives and insights, leading to a more comprehensive understanding of the work to be done. This collaborative approach promotes better decision-making and improves the quality of the estimates.
Accountability: Planning Poker promotes accountability by ensuring that all team members participate in the estimation process. Each team member has an equal opportunity to provide their input, and the consensus-driven approach ensures that everyone’s opinions are considered in the final estimation. This approach helps reduce the risk of individuals feeling marginalized and increases their sense of ownership over the estimation process.
Shared Understanding of the Product Backlog Items: Planning Poker helps promote a shared understanding of the product backlog items among team members. The discussion during the estimation process allows team members to ask questions, clarify assumptions, and identify potential roadblocks, resulting in a more comprehensive understanding of the work to be done. This shared understanding helps improve collaboration and decision-making throughout the development process.
Improved Planning and Prioritization: Planning Poker provides accurate and reliable estimates that help teams plan and prioritize their work effectively. These estimates enable teams to identify potential roadblocks early in the process, allowing them to take proactive measures to address them. This approach helps teams deliver high-quality products within the given timelines and budget.

In conclusion, Planning Poker is a valuable technique in Agile development that offers several benefits, including reduced bias and variance, increased team collaboration, accountability, shared understanding of product backlog items, and improved planning and prioritization. By using this technique, teams can make more accurate and reliable estimates, resulting in higher quality products delivered on time and within budget.

Are you ready to start or advance your Scrum career? Book a call with a coach today

Planning Poker Techniques

Planning Poker is a versatile technique that can be adapted to suit the needs of different teams and projects. Here are some of the techniques that can be used to conduct Planning Poker:

Standard Planning Poker: In standard Planning Poker, each team member is given a set of cards with different numbers representing the effort required to complete a particular task. The team discusses the task, and each member selects a card that represents their estimate. The cards are then revealed simultaneously, and the team discusses any discrepancies and works towards a consensus estimate.
Modified Planning Poker: Modified Planning Poker involves using a different set of cards or alternative ways of estimating the effort required for a task. For example, Fibonacci numbers can be used instead of standard numbers to reflect the increased uncertainty associated with larger tasks. Alternatively, t-shirt sizes (small, medium, large) can be used to represent the relative effort required for different tasks.
Multi-Round Planning Poker: Multi-Round Planning Poker involves conducting multiple rounds of estimation to help reduce the variance in the estimates. After each round, team members discuss their estimates and work towards a consensus estimate. The process continues until the estimates converge, resulting in a more accurate estimate.

Best Practices for Conducting Planning Poker:

Set a Time Limit: To keep the estimation process moving, it’s important to set a time limit for each round. Typically, a time limit of 5-10 minutes per round is sufficient.
Allow Team Members to Share their Rationale: During the estimation process, team members should be encouraged to share their rationale for their estimates. This approach helps promote a shared understanding of the task and improves the quality of the estimates.
Facilitate Discussion: The facilitator plays a critical role in the estimation process by ensuring that everyone has an opportunity to participate and that the discussion remains focused on the task at hand. The facilitator should encourage open and honest discussion and guide the team towards a consensus estimate.
Use Consensus-based Decision Making: Consensus-based decision making involves working towards an agreement that everyone can support. This approach helps ensure that everyone’s perspectives are considered, and the resulting estimate reflects the shared understanding of the team.

In conclusion, Planning Poker is a flexible estimation technique that can be adapted to suit the needs of different teams and projects. By using techniques such as standard Planning Poker, modified Planning Poker, and multi-round Planning Poker, teams can arrive at accurate and reliable estimates. By following best practices such as setting a time limit for each round, allowing team members to share their rationale, facilitating discussion, and using consensus-based decision making, teams can maximize the benefits of Planning Poker and deliver high-quality products within the given timelines and budget.

Common Pitfalls in Planning Poker

While Planning Poker is an effective technique for estimating the effort required for a task, there are common pitfalls that can arise if not properly addressed. Here are some of the common pitfalls and how to avoid them:

Bias: Bias can occur when team members are influenced by factors outside the scope of the task, such as previous experience, individual preferences, or personal biases. To avoid bias, team members should focus on the task at hand and refrain from considering extraneous factors.
Anchoring: Anchoring occurs when the first estimate provided by a team member influences the subsequent estimates of other team members. To avoid anchoring, team members should be encouraged to provide their estimates independently and to share their rationale for their estimates before discussing them with other team members.
Groupthink: Groupthink occurs when team members conform to the opinions of others rather than expressing their own opinions. To avoid groupthink, team members should be encouraged to express their opinions freely and to engage in open and honest discussion.
Lack of Training: Lack of training in the technique can lead to inaccurate estimates and poor decision making. It’s important to ensure that team members are adequately trained in the technique before attempting to use it in estimation.
Lack of Consensus: Lack of consensus can occur when team members are unable to reach a shared understanding of the task. To avoid lack of consensus, team members should be encouraged to engage in open and honest discussion and to work towards a shared understanding of the task.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Planning Poker is a powerful technique that can help development teams accurately estimate the effort required for each product backlog item. By engaging in a collaborative discussion and consensus-building process, team members can arrive at a shared understanding of the complexity and effort required for each item, which can help increase team collaboration, accountability, and shared understanding of the product backlog items.

Planning Poker has several benefits, including the reduction of bias and variance in estimates, as well as the ability to increase team collaboration and shared understanding. However, it’s important to use best practices when conducting Planning Poker to avoid common pitfalls such as bias, anchoring, groupthink, lack of training, and lack of consensus.

Overall, Planning Poker is a valuable tool that can help development teams improve their estimation process and ultimately deliver high-quality products. By following best practices and engaging in open and honest discussion, teams can use Planning Poker to achieve accurate and reliable estimates, increase collaboration and accountability, and ultimately deliver successful projects.